skip to main content

my i think you should leave tier list

2025-06-30

summary: this is my personal ranking of the sketches within sketch comedy show i think you should leave with tim robinson.

look, i’ve been sitting on this for a year now and i want a place to post it. a list of every sketch from the comedy sketch series i think you should leave with tim robinson, ranked by power level.

is this an utterly deranged way of thinking about comedy? yes, but a lot of itysl fans seem to be like this, so take from that what you will.

huge shoutout to i think you should quote. another big shoutout to spreadsheets, which make for stealthily good markdown generation. (someone, somewhere is running their entire blog off of a spreadsheet, believe me.)

items within each tier are not in any particular order.

explanation of tiers
  1. S: the canon, sketches i constantly drag my friends to watch.
  2. A: wonderful sketches that have altered my brain chemistry and personal lexicon forever.
  3. B: great sketches that just aren’t as good as the A-tier, but still pretty good.
  4. C: they’re funny but nothing special.
  5. D: i found that most in this tier were very quirky actually (compared to C), just not very funny to me.
  6. E: these just feel incomplete or are flawed in some way. or, they’re one half of a two-parter sketch and merely exists as setup or denouement.
  7. F: unfunny to me, unfortunately.

S—Gimme that! (13)

A—Looks like Christmas came early. (21)

B—It’s simply too good. (17)

C—Very meat and potatoes… (17)

D—That’s a Chunky! (8)

E—Shouldn’t have had such a sloppy mud pie. (6)

F—I don’t wanna be around anymore. (4)